As soon as I got Ellie, my black-eyed, bat-eared German shepherd puppy, I trained her to be a good dog. And so she was. When I spoke, she listened; she kept her barks quiet and her teeth clean. Two years on, I started to think she was a little too obedient. There was something pitiful about the way that, even unleashed in the park, she would stop at a fork in the path and look to me to point the way. In the house, she would pause behind a half-closed door instead of pushing through. She was hesitant, whining when she was unsure of herself, in a way that clashed with her big muscles and pointy canines. One day, when the cat in our local bodega poked its head out of the store, Ellie squealed like a child.
Listen to this article with reporter commentaryHer training, I saw, had come at the cost of something precious. Her independence, certainly. But also, something more intrinsic — something like her animality.
Ellie’s dad — my partner, Jesse — agreed. “I think she needs more self-confidence,” he said.
The solution, maybe, was buttons. Around this time, I started to see dogs on social media seeming to express their desires by the most absurdly simple, low-tech means possible: stepping on multicolored plastic buttons on the floor, each disc emitting a word when the dog pressed it. I scrolled through videos on my phone of dogs pawing FOOD and MORE and NOW, sometimes in that order.
rich88 slotThe most famous was Bunny, a lanky sheepadoodle in Tacoma, Wash., with 8.6 million TikTok followers, a vocabulary of 105 buttons and a diagnosis of generalized anxiety disorder. Bunny’s online store sold a starter pack of six buttons for $65. Through the buttons, Bunny reported her experience of the world. She said LOOK CAT. She was frequently CONCERNED. She seemed to have restless dreams about a STRANGER ANIMAL. A favorite topic of conversation was poop, as in POOP PLAY.
@whataboutbunny Dad callouts are my fave #callout #poopy #funnydog #communication #dogtok ♬ original sound - I am Bunny bl777 officialWe are having trouble retrieving the article content.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings.
Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.
Thank you for your patience while we verify access.
Already a subscriber? Log in.
The problem appeared to affect voters who were issued driver’s licenses before 1996, eight years before Arizona enacted a law in 2004 that required voters to provide proof of citizenship to be able to participate in state elections.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.rich9
